Comments on: Performance http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/ Indian stock picking community. Sun, 21 Mar 2010 20:13:44 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.7.1 hourly 1 By: rohit http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-894 rohit Sat, 05 Sep 2009 01:47:06 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-894 Hi silver<br>i am not sure how the return is calculated ..i am assuming it must be a plain average. the computation is done by a moneyvidya formulae ..i dont have access to the formulae Hi silver
i am not sure how the return is calculated ..i am assuming it must be a plain average. the computation is done by a moneyvidya formulae ..i dont have access to the formulae

]]> By: tipguy http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-893 tipguy Fri, 04 Sep 2009 00:40:12 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-893 Rohit,<br><br>There is a perceived notion that <a href="http://moneyvidya.com" rel="nofollow">moneyvidya.com</a> site is oriented toward traders and speculative stock picks. The long term value focused investors do not have any role to pay here. However, I believe it provides an excellent platform for all types of investors to be rated among the peers on a community basis. Yes, it would help to have a feature that allows removal of stocks at a future date. Although, I think that needs to be bounded by some aspect otherwise there will be a tendency of not closing winning position to keep ratings/returns higher. <br><br>Congratulations on the performance. It does show that ideas discussed on your blog are highly rated by an independent platform. It gives an independent rating to your ideas. Everybody touts their own horns, but there are very few to demonstrate it like you did. <br><br>Best Wishes,<br>TIP Guy Rohit,

There is a perceived notion that moneyvidya.com site is oriented toward traders and speculative stock picks. The long term value focused investors do not have any role to pay here. However, I believe it provides an excellent platform for all types of investors to be rated among the peers on a community basis. Yes, it would help to have a feature that allows removal of stocks at a future date. Although, I think that needs to be bounded by some aspect otherwise there will be a tendency of not closing winning position to keep ratings/returns higher.

Congratulations on the performance. It does show that ideas discussed on your blog are highly rated by an independent platform. It gives an independent rating to your ideas. Everybody touts their own horns, but there are very few to demonstrate it like you did.

Best Wishes,
TIP Guy

]]> By: silver http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-892 silver Wed, 02 Sep 2009 08:59:26 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-892 rohit how is this 69% calculated ? Is it a plain average of all the returns of your picks ? rohit how is this 69% calculated ? Is it a plain average of all the returns of your picks ?

]]> By: rohit http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-891 rohit Tue, 01 Sep 2009 01:37:33 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-891 Hi silver<br>i am not taking any offence from your comment. i really mean that an 8 month outperformance is not really statistically significant.<br>your understanding of how i have calculated outperformance is correct ...the moneyvidya portfolio- index return during the same period is around 20%. ofcourse this keeps changing on a daily basis.<br>i personally consider a 2-3 yr performance or more to be significant in terms of outperforming index. shorter time periods can be due to luck - both good or bad Hi silver
i am not taking any offence from your comment. i really mean that an 8 month outperformance is not really statistically significant.
your understanding of how i have calculated outperformance is correct …the moneyvidya portfolio- index return during the same period is around 20%. ofcourse this keeps changing on a daily basis.
i personally consider a 2-3 yr performance or more to be significant in terms of outperforming index. shorter time periods can be due to luck - both good or bad

]]> By: silver http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-890 silver Mon, 31 Aug 2009 09:33:14 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-890 @rohit, don't misunderstand me. I am only trying to understand how did you calculate relative performance. Our outperformance? <br>Is it simply that BSE Index in timeframe returned X <br>You returned Y.<br><br>Y-X = outperformance i.e 20% @rohit, don't misunderstand me. I am only trying to understand how did you calculate relative performance. Our outperformance?
Is it simply that BSE Index in timeframe returned X
You returned Y.

Y-X = outperformance i.e 20%

]]> By: jagoinvestor http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-888 jagoinvestor Sat, 29 Aug 2009 02:14:59 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-888 @Rohit <br><br>Good job :) . <br><br>Manish @Rohit

Good job :) .

Manish

]]> By: rohit http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-887 rohit Fri, 28 Aug 2009 23:01:46 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-887 Hi silver<br>the index is BSE index. the outperformance is for the period jan09 to current date. <br><br>however the above outperformance is not meaningful. an outperformance for an 8 month period can easily be a fluke.<br><br>regards<br>rohit Hi silver
the index is BSE index. the outperformance is for the period jan09 to current date.

however the above outperformance is not meaningful. an outperformance for an 8 month period can easily be a fluke.

regards
rohit

]]> By: silver http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/performance/comment-page-1/#comment-885 silver Thu, 27 Aug 2009 10:10:34 +0000 http://www.moneyvidya.com/blog/?p=2863#comment-885 @rohit how can you say that the dummy portfolio has beaten the index by 20% which index? <br>I am not trying to challenge you here, just wanted to get more insight on the performance. <br><br>Kudos to you for such a good performance. @rohit how can you say that the dummy portfolio has beaten the index by 20% which index?
I am not trying to challenge you here, just wanted to get more insight on the performance.

Kudos to you for such a good performance.

]]>