The crash of the Indian Stock Market since January 2008 has been widely attributed to FIIs pulling their money out to meet liabilities and redemptions. According to this article, however, FIIs have only pulled out $12.7bn and still have another $53.7bn, or almost Rs. 270,000 Cr. left in the market. 

A lot of market experts are talking about the market being near the bottom (”Valuations just cannot get any cheaper! The Indian growth story is sound, even at 7%!”) Let’s be clear on this: these falling prices are not about fundamentals - its simply about lack of liquidity. FIIs are not exiting the market because they want to, but because they are being forced to - nobody wants to book such massive losses, and nobody would argue against the fact that as an emerging market India is looking pretty cheap.

The fact that there’s so much FII money still in the market - 80% - is quite scary Read the rest of this entry »

Manmohan Singh prepared a Working Paper for the International Monetary Fund in December 2007, in light of the curbs imposed by the Securities and Exchanges Board of India (SEBI). It clearly explains the history and origins of P-notes and suggested at the time what the impact of the curb may be.

Some history:

Since 1992, when FIIs were allowed to invest in Indian equity markets after the balance of payments crisis, an offshore market for PNs developed as a primary conduit for foreign investors to invest in India.

The origins of such flows stems from the bilateral tax treaty that India has had with Mauritius. The main provision of the 1983 treaty was that no resident of Mauritius would be taxed in India on capital gains arising from the sale of securities in India. The treaty therefore gave capital gains exemption for investments routed via Mauritius. Despite the uniform reduction in capital gains tax arbitrage that existed from the early 1990s through July 2004, it is interesting to note that there has been a rapid growth in the market for PNs in the last three to four years.

In the decade, short term capital gains have been as high as 40% and long term capital gains as high as 20%. However, since July 2004, the tax treatment on short term (security held for less than 1 year) capital gainshave been reduced to 10%, and there are no taxes Read the rest of this entry »